Stocks in 401(k) Plans? Why Not?

A recent article at the Wall Street Journal’s explains why mutual funds

still charge fees, despite the fact that the transaction costs for stocks, bonds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are getting cheaper. According to an industry spokesperson, customers are paying for a service they are not receiving from other investments, namely fund managers trying to get the best rate of return possible for their investors. But for most actively managed funds, no matter how poorly they perform, fees aren’t cheap. It makes me wonder a couple of things: first, could I do a better job than fund managers, and second, why shouldn’t 401(k) plans offer the option of employees to buy whatever stocks they choose that are available on the New York Stock Exchange? I am not suggesting that an employee’s company stock be the only option; we saw what happened in the 1990s. (Remember Enron.)

But perhaps the average person could do better. Say, for example, that we played a game reminiscent of “pin the tail on the donkey,” where a blindfolded me attempts to pick stocks from the WSJ’s biggest page C5 (referring to today’s edition) posted on the wall. If I picked 10 of them and checked back a year later, would I have done better than a fund manager? Maybe not. But even if I failed I would not be paying an exuberant amount to do so. If I had purchased ten stocks through an online brokerage without the bells and whistles, I would have likely paid no more than $70 to $100 total in transaction costs regardless of the amount I invested. There would be no additional costs until I sold the stocks. Of course, the idea of anybody actually managing their own 401(k) plan mortifies anybody sitting on the House Education and Labor Committee. After all, isn’t the problem with investing is that too many employees are left on their own, having to make frightful and potentially financially fatal decisions? No,

I think the problem is the opposite: too many decisions about investing are left in the hands of others…whether it is policymakers, employers or fund managers.

A few blogs ago, I commented on the new Department of Labor disclosure rules regarding 401(k) fees. Bottom line is they should be easy to read and understand, not like a three-foot long phone bill, and should explicitly state the rate of return on a fund after fees are calculated. If more disclosure eventually forces fees down, fine. But employees need more than just additional disclosure of mutual fund fees. They need more options would force fund managers to compete with the likes of cheap and efficient online brokerage services.

Comments (7)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Joe Barnett says:

    More employers would offer Self-Directed 401(k) Accounts as an option in their plans if their employees requested it.

  2. Omar says:

    You can also make money on a breakout . That’s a stock that’s hititng a new trading high or low that day.You can also make money by scalping , or getting a thin piece of a rapidly-rising stock’s upward momentum. Buy 1,000 shares of a $ 35 stock, hold it for 10 seconds, and sell it for $ 35 1/8.Of course, that’s if you’re any good. Many people just don’t get it.Jane B

  3. Kristine says:

    There are a few possible legal pitfalls and you need tto do your due diligence to avoid
    them. It’s not just that, you want to learn how too mawke money fast and easy online.
    then we can help you learn what you need to know about designing a website with

    My weeb page … computer work at home (

  4. Francis says:

    It’s awesome to visit this site and reading the views of all mates regarding this post, while
    I am also eager of getting knowledge.

    Feell free to surtf to my homepage; Relationship Advice Cupidspulse

  5. Lorena says:

    Simρly want to say your article is as amazing. The clearness for your post is
    simplү еxcellent and that i could sսppose you’re a professional on this subject.
    Well together with your permission let me to clutch үour RSS feed to stay updated with forthcoming
    post. Thanks a million and please keep up the gratifying work.

    my page nba 2k15 locker codes

  6. Claudette says:

    A Double Layered Vest is a clever product for gynecomastia and a truly unique one at that, with its double
    layered compression panel throughout the front of the
    garment. t want to delve into the nitty-gritty details of Darwin. Take the Grow Bone Challenge and be
    sure to also eat a diet rich in calcium and vitamin D,
    and chances are that by 2020, no matter what your age, you’ll be
    more likely to have strong, healthy bones.
    With the new personal account, players can now start
    playing the game while downloading, which makes the whole platform more
    convenient and handy. Only through setting your own personal goals can you hope to elicit the motivation to stay focused and persistent.
    The beauty of refurbished products is that what you see is what you get.
    A bi-lingual associate from the law firm will accompany you to all the needed visits to government offices for fingerprinting, signatures, photos etc.

    During our follow-up session in 2011 to fine-tune that strategy,
    the Board was able to report remarkable progress in realizing the
    organization’s dream. With millions of dollars and countless jobs on the line, it is hard to
    blame them for their caution. Miss Del Rey posed next to her beloved vintage SL Mercedes red car, which weighed 3,521 pounds and was propelled by one of two engines: a 3-liter V-6 mustering either
    340 horsepower or 380 horsepower, and the brand’s 5-liter V-8 generating 495 horsepower.
    Can be startling at first since it looks like a sword.
    The Orlando Magic advanced to the NBA finals after defeating the best team
    going into the series in a Far Cry 4-2 series.
    This clamshell phone has two screens, one which is opened vertically for normal phone use and another
    which opens horizontally which lets you watch movies in the landscape format without breaking your wrists.
    We do not take checks because they take longer to clear (30
    days) than the program requires to complete. After uploading
    the site a final testing is conducted. In 2009, I was asked
    to help a non-profit organization develop a business strategy.
    As a woman gets older, the chances of having heart diseases increase
    as well. Video Card – be careful there, serious gamers do not look at Ge – Force 210
    or ATI 4650 cards – they are good for low budget,
    but you will see HUGE performance increase if you get at least ATI 5670 or
    9800GT. When sell new product, there is one thing you need to know that when the consumers do shopping, the visual
    sensory of product always better determine the consumers to purchase than other elements.
    They require a different testing strip with regard to test.
    The restaurant industry is comprised of more than 500,000 locations with more than $400
    billion USD per year in gross revenue. Doing jobs for the arms dealer will unlock other
    weapons and upgrades. In some cases, the woman may decide to marry the dependable bloke.
    “It seems that everything is about money now,” you
    say with frustration in your voice. USA cars are about same price
    without the discounts which are better in USA.

  7. Marcelo says:

    Superb blog! Do you have any hints for aspiring writers? I’m hoping to
    start my own site soon but I’m a little lost on everything.
    Would you suggest starting with a free platform like WordPress
    or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m totally overwhelmed ..

    Any tips? Bless you! punci

Leave a Reply

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.