Stocks in 401(k) Plans? Why Not?

A recent article at the Wall Street Journal’s explains why mutual funds

still charge fees, despite the fact that the transaction costs for stocks, bonds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are getting cheaper. According to an industry spokesperson, customers are paying for a service they are not receiving from other investments, namely fund managers trying to get the best rate of return possible for their investors. But for most actively managed funds, no matter how poorly they perform, fees aren’t cheap. It makes me wonder a couple of things: first, could I do a better job than fund managers, and second, why shouldn’t 401(k) plans offer the option of employees to buy whatever stocks they choose that are available on the New York Stock Exchange? I am not suggesting that an employee’s company stock be the only option; we saw what happened in the 1990s. (Remember Enron.)

But perhaps the average person could do better. Say, for example, that we played a game reminiscent of “pin the tail on the donkey,” where a blindfolded me attempts to pick stocks from the WSJ’s biggest page C5 (referring to today’s edition) posted on the wall. If I picked 10 of them and checked back a year later, would I have done better than a fund manager? Maybe not. But even if I failed I would not be paying an exuberant amount to do so. If I had purchased ten stocks through an online brokerage without the bells and whistles, I would have likely paid no more than $70 to $100 total in transaction costs regardless of the amount I invested. There would be no additional costs until I sold the stocks. Of course, the idea of anybody actually managing their own 401(k) plan mortifies anybody sitting on the House Education and Labor Committee. After all, isn’t the problem with investing is that too many employees are left on their own, having to make frightful and potentially financially fatal decisions? No,

I think the problem is the opposite: too many decisions about investing are left in the hands of others…whether it is policymakers, employers or fund managers.

A few blogs ago, I commented on the new Department of Labor disclosure rules regarding 401(k) fees. Bottom line is they should be easy to read and understand, not like a three-foot long phone bill, and should explicitly state the rate of return on a fund after fees are calculated. If more disclosure eventually forces fees down, fine. But employees need more than just additional disclosure of mutual fund fees. They need more options would force fund managers to compete with the likes of cheap and efficient online brokerage services.

Comments (6)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Joe Barnett says:

    More employers would offer Self-Directed 401(k) Accounts as an option in their plans if their employees requested it.

  2. Omar says:

    You can also make money on a breakout . That’s a stock that’s hititng a new trading high or low that day.You can also make money by scalping , or getting a thin piece of a rapidly-rising stock’s upward momentum. Buy 1,000 shares of a $ 35 stock, hold it for 10 seconds, and sell it for $ 35 1/8.Of course, that’s if you’re any good. Many people just don’t get it.Jane B

  3. Arielle says:

    Catholic homeschooling curricula offer lessons which might be at par while using level
    oof national academic standards and that means you won’t worry about your yohngster lagging behind children of his age and proficiency.
    If your kids give their disability an excessive amount
    off consideration, it will become a anchor that drags them, and will become a justification to not even try.
    I hope that I have enlightened that you bit onn
    maintaining an organized homeschooling environment.

    my web pge :: modul bimbel

  4. Grace says:

    That iss the reason why proper guidance for every type
    of issue widely available that can help you to move through this process.
    The tudy finds the reason why too be the volume of language these children were exposed to.
    Thanks ffor thee easy and affordability of video teleconferencing, your youngster can now hook upp with tutors around the word or around the globe.

    Here iss my page modul bimbingan belajar

  5. Shawn says:

    If yoou find yourself getting a family outdoor tents much lower that
    $100, then most likely you will maake anther financial deal with
    upgrade soon there after your first trip. If you’re running inexepensively,
    you’ll bee able to always find an Amazon coupon on your item.

    You can browse tents of all sizes and models to discover the one that fits your family’s needs.

    Allso visit my page … Cara mendapatkan pulsa gratis

  6. Abby says:

    Coconut oil is needed for frying, andd also the flesh you consume
    as a condiment. That’ll help keep you safe and sound while
    reaping the oil’s health benefits. Sweet butt low carbohydrate apricots
    truly are wonderful summer fruits that could
    be listed because the best fruits for diabetics.

    Feel ffree too visit my website … Jual Bibit Durian Bawor

Leave a Reply

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.