Retiring Soon? Pay off the House First

houseIn 2011, the first of some 78 million baby boomers began retirement.  By the year 2031, the last year of the boomer generation will reach their full retirement age (67).  Many will consider moving to a less costly, low-tax state in an effort to reduce their living expenses.  However, more than half of those on the verge of retirement —  55 to 64 year olds —  are still carrying mortgage debt, and some households will carry it into retirement for many years to come.  How will this affect their lifetime wealth?

Using the NCPA’s State Tax Calculator, I compared the tax burden from state to state, as measured by the amount of lifetime spendable income after taxes and housing or rental expense.  Our calculator accounts for federal and state income taxes, median property taxes, and state and local average sales taxes for each state.  But regardless of where retirees choose to spend their golden years, mortgage debt could significantly reduce lifetime wealth.

Consider the example of a 64-year-old individual living in New Jersey, with one of the highest tax burdens, who plans on moving to Texas (a state with one of the lowest tax burdens) and retiring at age 65.  He currently earns $75,000 a year, and has a home valued in New Jersey at $300,000 with $50,000 left on his mortgage.

  • If he moves to Texas, purchases a home for $300,000 and assumes a $50,000 mortgage for 20 years, his monthly payments will be low ($642 a month at a 5 percent fixed rate) but he will gain only $242 a year in annual discretionary income for the rest of his life.  Assuming he lives to age 100, his lifetime gain will total only $12,026.
  • If he instead purchases a $250,000 home and pays it in full at the time of purchase (using the proceeds from his previous home), he will gain an additional $5,405 in annual discretionary income, resulting in an additional accumulation in lifetime wealth of $239,226!

There are two factors at play here.  First, despite Texas’ overall low tax burden, the state’s median property tax rate is about the same as New Jersey.  Even though property taxes and interest payments are both tax deductible, they are not enough to reduce his federal tax burden and increase his wealth.  However, purchasing a slightly less expensive home and paying it in full, as in the second example, increases his wealth by reducing property taxes and interest payments.

Does more housing mean more wealth?  Consider a couple earning $200,000 a year considering a move from New York to the lower tax state of Florida.  One spouse, who is 64, will retire in a year.  They own a $400,000 home in New York with a $169,000 mortgage balance left to pay over 15 years.

  • If they move to Florida, where tax rates are lower, and purchase a home for the same price as their home in New York (with a $250,000 down payment and a 15-year mortgage), they will have an additional $3,300 to spend each year during their lifetime.
  • However, they can triple their additional discretionary income each year in Florida to more than $9,000 by simply “downsizing” to a $250,000 home and purchasing it outright.

When considering a move for their senior years, whether to another state or another home in the same state, retirees should look at the pros and cons of carrying a mortgage.  While paying down higher-interest debt, such as credit cards, should take first priority, those who have only mortgage debt should think carefully before taking on another mortgage or extending their existing one.

Comments (32)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Rudolph says:

    “In 2011, the first of some 78 million baby boomers began retirement.”

    Not as many as we need to have retire.

  2. Mark says:

    “However, more than half of those on the verge of retirement — 55 to 64 year olds — are still carrying mortgage debt, and some households will carry it into retirement for many years to come.”

    The generational start of living beyond our means.

  3. Jackson says:

    “living in New Jersey”

    How horrible.

  4. Kevin says:

    “who plans on moving to Texas”

    Going from one of the worst to the best.

  5. Wilbur says:

    “However, purchasing a slightly less expensive home and paying it in full, as in the second example, increases his wealth by reducing property taxes and interest payments.”

    It shouldn’t be surprising that living modestly makes you more money.

  6. Jackson says:

    “If they move to Florida”

    With the other retirees…

  7. Billy says:

    The best advice here is to buy a home outright instead of mortgaging it.

  8. Trent says:

    “When considering a move for their senior years, whether to another state or another home in the same state, retirees should look at the pros and cons of carrying a mortgage.”

    Absolutely.

  9. Lucas says:

    How else could we speed them up?

  10. Earl says:

    The writer also fails to mention that a person living in NJ can purchase a bigger house for less money in Fl. Then they can pay cash, have a nice house, no debt, and greater disposable income. Win/win/win. Oh, yeah and no state income tax! And the FL gov. is preparing to lower property taxes. They have a budget surplus. Not to mention much better weather!!!

  11. Jeff says:

    The monthly principal and interest payment for a $50,000 mortgage for 20 years @ 5% is $329.98, which is $3,959.73 per year. The first year interest would be $2,466.08. How do you calculate the $5,405 of annual discretionary income in your example of the person who moves to Texas and does not take out a mortgage?

    • Pam says:

      Because the state tax calculator factors in other differences between the 2 states, such as property taxes and state income taxes. So the additional $5,405 is not just the absence of an interest payment is also the variation in tax burden.

  12. Jeff says:

    The tax burden between New Jersey and Texas should have already been factored into the $242 calculation. Purchasing a $250K home without a mortgage will not result in a savings or increase in discretionary income of
    $5,405 annually, when compared to purchasing a $300K home with a $50K mortgage.

  13. Michell says:

    I used to be able to find good advice from your content.

    Look at my web blog – reviews of derm exclusive fill and freeze

  14. 60SecondPanicSolution

    Retiring Soon? Pay off the House First | Retirement Reform Policy | NCPA.org

  15. Jane says:

    Heya i’m for the first time here. I came across this board and I to find It really helpful & it
    helped me out a lot. I hope to provide something again and help others like you
    aided me.

    Here is my web-site – salaon head massage

  16. Lieselotte says:

    Hello, after reading this awesome paragraph i aam tooo delighted
    to share my experience here witrh mates.

    Feel free to visut mmy blog: free (Ali)

  17. Sophia says:

    It’s amazing for me to have a site, which is useful for my know-how.
    thanks admin

    my page pumpkin patches long island

  18. best products for younger skin

    Retiring Soon? Pay off the House First | Retirement Reform Policy | NCPA.org

  19. Stewart says:

    I am truly happy to glance at this webpage posts which
    consists of plenty of helpful information, thanks for providing these
    kinds of data.

    my page; Boom Beach Hack; Hildegard,

  20. Demetra says:

    In fields of postmodern artwork, fragmentation signifies the
    breaking rather than building up of information, to form
    a structure that would convey a hidden message rather than the obvious message to its audience.
    Emperor Manuel I Komnenos died in 1180 leaving an incompetent successor.

    ” One of those grand narratives, which in fact was the one that singlehandedly dominated the way of thinking of the modern world, was the notion that Enlightenment thinkers conquered ignorance and superstitions of the pre-modern world by promoting scientific knowledge to replace religiously laden ideas considered to be the culprit of centuries old of intellectual and cultural stagnancy.

    Have a look at my webpage – forge of
    empires gratuit

  21. Dewey says:

    However, if you are remodeling your kitchen, you should preserve the originality of your kitchen and only apply essential components from the new layout that
    you have picked, this kind of as only including stools but trying to keep other things, or maybe only rearranging the placement of the components of
    the existing island. Cabinetry alone accounts for close to
    50% of the total cost of the project – eating up half of your
    budget before you even blink. If you have you ought to really just simply following that link.

    my page; copper repipe pompano beach club

  22. Marcela says:

    After a quick lunch and a brief nap back at the mobile home, we resumed fishing about three o’clock and fished
    all the way until dark. The old art of stealth
    in carp fishing seems to be as dead as the dodo on most carp waters today and it seems to me
    that the average carp angler is so manically driven to
    get in a swim set up and cast out they have no idea it is far
    better to think like the fish and not an angler first and
    truly give carp the respect they deserve that will
    guarantee to give them the catches their strive so manically for.
    Of course, lots of methods have evolved to try to avoid spooking fish
    out of your swim or even stop them from stopping feeding in the possible case of some line shy fish, and having them leave your swim.

    my web site marine refrigerator Styrofoam insulation panels

  23. Website designer Jacksonville

    Retiring Soon? Pay off the House First | Retirement Reform Policy | NCPA.org

  24. Hollis says:

    What’s up, this weekend is good for me, for the reason that this point in time i am reading this impressive informative
    piece of writing here at my home.

    My page appliance hauling

  25. Margart says:

    My brother suggested I may like this website. He was once entirely right.
    This submit truly made my day. You can not consider simply how a lot time I had
    spent for this information! Thank you!

    My web site free ladyboy cams (http://www.aixpan.com)

  26. Lidia says:

    As you travel with Worldmate for Nokia N73 you do not need to
    worry about the currency conversion rates as Worldmate will take care of that
    for you. Randomly spotty it almost looks insidiously contagious.
    Thus, compared with likers, haters could be
    characterized as less active because they do fewer things, or they could be characterized as more focused because
    they spend more time on the small number of things they do.

    my blog … free likes

Leave a Reply



If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.