Income Inequality from a Plain-Spoken Perspective

Earlier this week, I participated in a televised panel discussion on income inequality.  The topic has generated much discussion lately, as President Obama’s central theme has been how to fix the gap between the rich and the poor.  My general thought is it simply cannot be fixed by dragging out the usual redistribution solutions – raising the minimum wage, taxing the rich, etc. On the other hand, I think the answer does not lie with artificial wage floors and punitive taxation.  The market should determine wages, and all income earners, not just lower-income earners, should be encouraged to work, invest and earn even more income without taxes designed to soak the rich.  So will this help the top 20 percent?  You bet it will., but it will help everyone else too.

How dare I stick up for the top 20 percent, or the top 1 percent, or even the top 1/10 of a percent.  Am I the enemy?  Before you judge, allow me to reflect on my life experiences.  When I graduated from high school, I had no desire to go to college.  In fact, even though I did fairly well in school, by the time I graduated I never wanted to sit in a classroom again.  So I started my first full-time job in retail at minimum wage (which I will not disclose to you lest I date myself).   I stayed in retail for a year, worked my way up to a slightly better-paying customer service position, then left to work in the hotel industry.  This was something I had always wanted to do.  During my first two years, I earned enough to move out on my own, buy a new but modest car, get a decent apartment, and buy a few new clothes.  Did I have trouble making ends meet?  Occasionally I did, but my income continued to increase as I learned all I could about hotel sales and administration.  However, it never dawned on me to resent the hotel general manager, who earned several times what I did.  As far as I was concerned, I did not envy him one bit for dealing with the daily unpleasantries of running a hotel full of picky guests and sometimes unreliable employees.

When I got married years later, I had tapped out my potential as a high school graduate in a hotel career.  If I wanted to earn more at the hotel or at any other professional job in my fields of interest, I needed more education, so I went to college.  My husband and I scraped up money to send me to college on a pay-as-I-went basis without student loans while we spent the rest of our money paying the mortgage and a car loan.  No room for luxuries here.

Fast forward several years later – I am not by any means in the top 1 percent, but I am not in the tight financial position I was 25 years ago.  This is rather typical for most families.  As people get older, marry (or not), obtain more work experience and get more education under their belt, they tend to earn more.  In fact, peak earning years are in the 50s.  In other words, very few people start off high on the curve; they have to climb it.  This is known as income mobility.

But how much does this help anybody else?  A great deal, actually.  As people work more and earn more, they have less time to do mundane tasks, so they pay somebody else to do them.  This is known as opportunity cost – the cost of an alternative that must be forgone in order to do something else.  For instance, I probably clean my house better than anybody else can, but because I put more value on leisure (because I have less of it), I would be willing to pay somebody else to clean so that I can flail around at Irish step-dancing, get my nails done, or curl up on the couch watching “Game of Thrones.” In essence, because I earn more, somebody else is earning money also by cleaning my house.  Moreover, somebody is earning money keeping up my yard because neither I or my better half want to spend leisure time mowing the yard.  Finally, I rely on my wonderful nail technician to sculpt my nails every few weeks; otherwise, my fingers would look like bloody stumps.

Sadly, the wonderful young lady that cleaned my house had to close up shop and pursue other opportunities.  Contrary to what the media might say about high-income earners, they lost money after 2008, forcing many of them to cut back on things they would pay others to do.  My nail technician struggled as people canceled their salon appointments.  Fortunately, the gentleman that years ago knocked on doors in my neighborhood and offered to mow laws for cheap now has a thriving business that has grown larger each year (hey, even in economic hard times, most Texans hate doing yard work in 105 degree weather).  Their businesses all enable them to support families, and when income earners in higher quintiles fail, so do they.

The point is…whenever economists talk about high-income households in defense of income inequality, they tend to ramble on about how Warren Buffet helps the capital markets by foregoing current consumption, how hedge fund managers buy faltering firms and turn them around, blah blah blah.  But in my plain-spoken world, it is much more simple.



Comments (14)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Joe Barnett says:

    Conversely, many people who are financially successful early in life end up penniless. There are plenty examples of athletes, actors and writers who achieved fame early, then flamed out, and because they consumed all their gains (and paid lots of taxes on what they earned), they outlived their earning power and their savings.

  2. SPM says:

    Similar stories apply to the vast majority of people. Everyone starts out “poor” at one time because they lack skills and experience, but they move up the ladder over time as they grow their skills.

    Instead of focusing on spreading the wealth as BHO does, what we need is a leader who focuses on motivating people to acquire the skills necessary to improve their lives (by simultaneously improving the lives of others by providing a good or service they want).

    The fallacy that redistributionists like Obama thrive on is that a higher minimum wage and more entitlements somehow helps people “get ahead.” While this deception is politically appealing, it destroys incentives for people to REALLY get ahead by taking ownership over their own futures. How sad!

  3. Gale says:

    Each season Jovani adds over 400 new dresses to their always expanding Collections; Jovani,
    Red Carpet, Dolce Jovani, Beyond, and Prom.
    There you have obtained it 4 aboveboard to attach to consideration in affiliation to in might maybe
    need of Herve Leger V guitar neck Bandage Dress Black. The multiple choice area makes up about 60%
    from the section’s score and also the simulations account for
    40% of the score.

    Check out my blog; motel floral bodycon dress

  4. Milagros says:

    Everyone wants cheap bait these days but the big problem is that cheap often means rubbish.

    Leave your windows open a few hours a day and then you get to clean the black soot off of the floors.
    Revealed in my unique readymade bait and homemade bait carp and catfish bait secrets ebooks is far
    more powerful information look up my unique website (Baitbigfish) and
    see my biography below for details of my ebooks deals right now.

    My web-site :: marine freezer option for jeanneau yachts

  5. Damion says:

    Deegan was arrested and charged with human trafficking and drug
    possession after cops busted in and found the girls
    being held hostage. But there is an exception if the caregiver
    is your parent. Avoid hype or gimmicks and let people know exactly what to expect and what they are
    required to do in order to receive what they are being offered.

    Feel free to surf to my web page :: Boca Raton entry level CPA jobs

  6. Terrie says:

    However, sometimes we need to do something a little more adventurous,
    or perhaps a little more pointedly self-serving.
    There are differences between Persian patients
    in the US as opposed to those in Iran. Often fine dining and jewelry discounts are offered.

    Here is my blog: plastic surgery youtube

  7. Grazyna says:

    You don’t know if you’re going to be able to attack the same way and
    dive on the floor the same way. Now I know that she has
    mentioned potential cosmetic surgery for her nose earlier, but this hit me tremendously hard.
    Their training and experience make them better qualified to
    perform plastic surgery procedures.

    Here is my webpage … Facial Plastic Surgeon Ann Arbor

  8. Pamela says:

    She has a charm that is slightly reminiscent of the childhood
    favourite Rosie and Jim’s Ragdoll, with a modernized interior to suit the 21st century traveller.
    The options within the area range from Myall Lakes houseboats, cottages, apartments, cabins and guests houses, lodges and
    hotels among many others. But have you ever thought about living
    in your boat full time.

    Also visit my webpage deck staining tools

  9. Loyd says:

    If you or someone you know thinks they may be pregnant or is experiencing any symptoms of pregnancy
    and acquires a negative test result, its best to test again in around a
    week. When the time comes to purchase HCG the very first time, making the effort to look, to check,
    and also to research prices and shipping costs
    is needed. Bones and nails are also strengthened,
    which is an important factor that effects more than your appearance.

    my web-site hcg weight loss for metabolic syndrome

  10. Levi says:

    But one big empty spot will be saved for Sarah ‘Barracuda’ Palin as she decided to be a no show for
    tonight’s debate. In some of the countries, the freighters can be charged
    or fined for being overweight so you can do your bit by making sure there is minimal fuel
    in your engine. Look for testimonials and suggestions that will help in making the job
    easy. When it is a matter of protection for your beloved pony, there
    is nothing better than Harlequin horse rugs.
    There are various Fast Moving Consumer Goods like meat, vegetables, fruits,
    dairy products, baked goods and so forth that
    are highly perishable. As a result of the water damage foul smell can choke your breath and mold grows in gradual process.
    A few years ago, logistics and transportation services were not as up to date as they are now.
    Since you are working inside a kitchen, you should know what
    the kitchen items are and their differences.
    One of them is the rising popularity of the equity release plans and schemes.
    Oil Recycling and filtration spend engine oil along with others are becoming more and more popular.

    Feel free to surf to my weblog … reliable West palm beach movers

  11. Regena says:

    Johnny Depp is another example of a celebrity who loves stylish sunglasses.

    This is because all of these challenges are already present all
    throughout your education. There is a certain type
    of fashion blogs content writing for which is done especially by prominent designers or their assigned
    group of website content writing professionals.

    My website; bodycon bandage dress reviews

  12. Juliann says:

    Comfort comes in the form of the beautifully upholstered reclinable
    deck seats and bow seats, and a drive. With the high temperature sensitivity of some
    perishable goods, it’s easy to understand why so many companies
    rely on vacuum insulated panels such a Thermo – Cor to ensure the quality of their products.

    Her husband, Ian, is a pilot at the New River Air Station near Camp

    Check out my web site :: marine refrigerator 22 conversion magpul kit for

  13. Johanna says:

    The enduring popularity of Venetian glass ornaments and Venetian glass
    jewelry is a proof that the saying is true. The classic man’s suit has
    barely changed for over a hundred years. , HCG Drops by knowing Dr Simeons HCG Diet and get advantages.

    Also visit my webpage – bodycon dresses buy online

  14. Casey says:

    Taking medicaltions or birth control pills will not effect pregnancy tests,
    unless of course your medication contains h – CG.
    When it came time to select the homeopathic h – CG product
    I would use for round two I was intrigued with the option of Homeopathic h –
    CG Pellets. s better not to test instead of wasting your health insurance and money on these fake, choose nothing diets.

    Review my blog post :: hcg weight loss testimonials

Leave a Reply

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.